Stuffed Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookies



Handcrafted, artisanal stuffed peanut butter and jelly cookies made with high quality ingredients, many of which are organic. Each order will consist of 6 large and decadent (4 oz) peanut butter cookies filled with organic strawberry jam baked fresh to order. I have spent years perfecting my recipes, and it is an absolute joy to be able to share my passion with you and your loved ones!

Orders are fulfilled and shipped Monday through Friday morning, and typically ship within one day to ensure you receive the freshest product possible. If you place your order between Friday afternoon and Sunday, your order will be processed and shipped on Monday.

Your cookies are carefully packed in a branded kraft bakery box lined with gift paper, and each cookie is individually wrapped in sealed bubble or cello sleeves to ensure they arrive to you in perfect condition. My packaging is naturally conducive for all of your gifting needs.

By default, each order come with a thoughtfully and intentionally chosen verse from the Bible in line with my mission to spread love through both baked goods and the Gospel. If you choose to opt out, please notify me in the notes section at checkout.

If you need your cookies within a specific time frame, or if you have any further inquiries, please contact me and I will do my best to accommodate you within my means.

Allergens: wheat, soy, dairy, egg, peanut (produced in a shared facility with all major allergens)

Shipping from United States

Processing time

1-3 business days

Estimated shipping times

  • North America : 1 - 2 business days

I'll do my best to meet these shipping estimates, but can't guarantee them. Actual delivery time will depend on the shipping method you choose.

Payment Options

Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

I don't accept returns, exchanges, or cancellations

But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you take custom and/or personalized orders?

I generally don't take custom orders, but feel free to message me with the details of your request. There may be a chance I'll be able to accommodate.

Can your cookies be heated up?

Short answer is yes! For the 4oz (large size) cookies I would recommend placing them on a cookie sheet in a preheated 350 degree oven for about 3 minutes. I wouldn't heat up the 2oz (smaller size) cookies for longer than 1-1.5 minutes. Results cannot be guaranteed as all oven temperatures vary slightly.

Information regarding allergens?

All allergen information is specified with its corresponding listing. My facility handles all major allergens though (eggs, wheat, dairy, soy, tree-nuts, peanuts, coconut, corn, sesame) so cross-contamination is possible. I would discourage anyone with allergies from ordering.

Do you offer returns or refunds?

I don't offer either, but if you have any issues with your order please don't hesitate to send me a message. The satisfaction of my customers is of upmost importance to me, and I'll do what I can to make things right!

Reviews (9)


HEAVENLY cookies delivered with an uplifting Bible verse! WONDERFUL creation... I've never tasted anything so delicious, and I'm a peanut butter cookie aficionado. Perfectly packaged and rapidly shipped too!!! AAA+++ seller!!

Erika is the best! She makes each cookie with love and it shows!!

Delicious peanut butter cookies! Loved how they were stuffed with jam AND peanut butter. I've ordered multiple times from this seller, and I've never been disappointed. Thanks Erica!

Unbelievable quality! . Packing was incredible ! We will be back !

Outstanding (and giant!) cookies, like a peanut butter and jelly sandwich but obviously way better because COOKIES! I've ordered from this shop multiple times, and everything is always delicious, made and packaged with care, and the shop owner very friendly and answers questions right away. And I love receiving the bible verse in each box. Can't wait to buy more for the holidays!

Legal imprint